Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I get the distance and I like the subject but the crop could be tighter. Maybe a 5.4
Post actions
Good guess and title in any challenge. Nice tonal range and I love the swirl of texture. I don't need as much on top but don't mind it, either. I gave it a 6 and think that's about what it will score.
Post actions
good to look at. 6. But you'll prolly get less from the dark phobics, say five pointthree.
Post actions
Too much extra space dilutes the impact of an otherwise good shot. I think more like a 5.45
Post actions
I see what you did there! Clever and nicely produced. I hadn't given you a six, but I will now. You might just make it. Guessing 5.98!
Post actions
I don't know what that means but I'm giving you a 6.
Post actions
Nice idea...it seems it would be better (to me) without all the negative space and maybe raise levels on black a tad. Good guess. 6.1
Post actions
Post actions
Great image. Looks like it could be in the booklet of a rock and roll bands CD sleeve
Post actions
I agree with you. 6 I love black and white
Post actions
I think this image is two dark to reach a score of six. I expect it to do about 5.0
Post actions
Fibonacci! And I like your humor. 5.5
Post actions
I gave it a six. Guessing a 5.6.
Post actions
Nice shape and light in B&W. Not sure if the top is adding much to the photo. 5.6371
Post actions
Interesting subject but I don't think the crop works for me. 5
Post actions
simple motiy, artsy pic - 6 from me and I predict 5.85
Post actions
5.8, but 6 is really quite fair.
Post actions
Yep, you convinced me. No, wait, this is a 6.30
Post actions
Six from me - and I have given it some consideration. (This would be at home in the Numbers challenge, wouldn't it?)
Post actions
Like this even more the in the second viewing! The texture is super. I thought this was a shell, but now I am not so sure. I hope you have photographer notes explaining what it is! 6.5
Post actions
6+ at least,,,,,,, love this,,,,,7 from us
Post actions
Clever. I think you're right 6.0
Post actions
Creative work. Has a fine art feel and I think the B&W works well. My estimate it 6.12
Post actions
Post actions
lots of subliminal 6's here....I still see a 5 in the picture.
Post actions
It has been done before, Too much black. 5.8
Post actions
Nicely lit object. I estimate a final score of 5.7
Post actions
Beautiful lighting. 9 from me.
Post actions
…some.. thing ooh compelling me I…must I have t o say…6 (and secretly vote a seven) Nice job good luck!
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
Nice placement, texture and the black and white really works. A 7
Post actions
5.798 (I gave it a seven)
Post actions
subliminal talks and given Love the black and white tones and the detail in the shell
Post actions
Almost an optical illusion
Post actions
An artistic and interesting approach. Somewhere between heaven and he77. 6.21
Post actions
Nice lighting and processing. I predict 6.1.
Post actions
Post actions
Score around 5.85 maybe, interesting but not great~
Post actions
I'm a fan of negative space, nice lighting too. I scored higher than: 6.18
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you estimated your score well, I gave you a six and I predict that you will finish at 5,9456
Post actions
these shells make great desighs and I think the lighting adds 6
Post actions
Post actions
Not bad but I think this could have been a tad better with a square crop.
Post actions
hehe, I see what you did here. :P
Post actions
Good one. Very su6liminal.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
