Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Sunrise and the loch ness monster.7 from me, 6.4 score guess.
Message edited by author 2015-02-09 14:21:58.
Post actions
great winter scene. I predict a 6 and I give you a 6.
Post actions
Moody blue and cold. Good atmosphere; I'll guess a 6.26.
Post actions
Nice depth of color in this stark winter scene 5.8
Post actions
A nice scene but had the funky processing been toned down I think it'd do better. I guess 5.8
Post actions
Quite crunchy-glowy - might not appeal to all. I'm not sure you'll hit your score. I think it's likely to emerge at around 5.6.
Post actions
I predict 5.88, I think the overcooking in the hdr might work against you.
Post actions
Very pretty...a bit hdrish which may hurt scores with some, but not the majority. I like it. 6.6
Post actions
Post actions
I really like the HDR processing but it seems a little overdone. Subject is not that interesting as well. I'll give a 6
Post actions
This is among a relatively small number of images that I think will score well. 6.3
Post actions
Lovely winter colors. And Nessie too. 5.9
Post actions
I gave it a five. Guessing a 5.6.
Post actions
Nice soft morning cold. 6.12
Post actions
nice reflection and morning colour cast - 6 from me and I predict 5.9
Post actions
I expect your score will be negatively impacted by the purplish tree branches. My guess is 5.4536.
Post actions
This image is well done, and interesting composition with good depth of focus, I agree with your score estimate of 6.25 I willl vote this a seven Good Luck
Post actions
a bit too much ghosting for me 5
Post actions
cool,,,,,8 from me,,,,,,, ends in in 6,5 i think,,,,
Post actions
Nice placement of the tree stump, it adds a very good focal point. The tones seem a little off to me though. My estimate is 6.10
Post actions
Post actions
Nice calm landscape. A little too blue on the water. 5.95
Post actions
love the tones here. accurate prediction, I concur on 6.25
Post actions
about right, maybe you're a tiny bit high. nice shot though. returning to guess: 5.43
Post actions
This is really pretty. The colours are beautiful. Seven from me, predicting that your own prediction of 6.25 is pretty close to the mark.
Post actions
I estimate a final score of 5.6
Post actions
Looks like a beautiful painting. An 8
Post actions
Pretty scene and well composed; the colours seem a little unusual to me. 6.18
Post actions
Maybe slightly optimistic. Nice landscape and well composed, but too HDR for my taste and the colors are off for me. I'd say 6.15
Post actions
6.5157 (I gave it a seven)
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
The purple tinge is a problem for me but I love the scene and reflection. I will vote this a five but I think the voters will likely squeak through with a 6 or better.
Post actions
Love nature photos like this so calming for me. I gave it a 5
Post actions
Post actions
Photogs historically identify with purple pixels as fringing. Which may not bode well for voting on this otherwise beautiful subject. Predict 5.31
Post actions
Score's about right, lovely pink sky, a bit overcooked though.
Post actions
Nice reflections and i like the stump in front. I predict 6.0.
Post actions
I would be surprised at 6.25 mid 5 I think
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you estimated your score a little high, I gave you a six but I predict that you will finish at 5,8983
Post actions
Nice landscape, but it's something about the purple that just doesn't look natural to me. I'm in just under your guess.
Post actions
OK My favorite aspect of this image is the mood, steeped in purple. Out strolling in late afternoon on a chilly day. By the way, fabulous "capture" of Nessie!
Post actions
I like the composition, but something about the colours turns me off. 5
Post actions
Reflection is splendid. 7
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
