Critique Club
Composition-Content
The composition is nice and simple, but if the picture was unprocessed, it probably wouldn't have a strong impact (IMO) What makes this picture is what you have done with it, unfortunately I haven't heard of solarize mode, but it seems to have an interesting effect. I am not sure how much of this effect was created in the camera and how much was through colour saturation and sharpening, but it is a technique which makes this picture stand out. I am not sure that this is the best type of shot to do this effect with, but it all comes down to@personal preferences, some people love it, some people hate it! Personally, I think that its great to play around with new techniques but I think that on this site, most people are not huge fans of it!
The black background sets the milk of nicely, there seems to be a bit of stray light which has been emaphasised in the processing stage, perhaps pointing the light away from the background would have helped. Also, the table is tilted, if this could be rotated a few degrees, it would help a lot.
Overall, I like the abstract nature of this shot, especially the different shades of colour on the table. Good Luck in the next challenge.
i wonder how many comments you are getting that this is a photography, and not a digital art website ... i like your shot a lot though. i especiallly like the pastries at the right and the different colors in the milk. the shadow and the background color make some interesting patterns. my only nitpick is that the background isn't quite straight, you might want to rotate CW a bit. good entry! :)
I kinda like the over sharpening to appear as a painting. But there appears to be a slant to the photo. Could just be my imagination. Good composition otherwise. Nice job. Different.
COOL! I love the crazy processing you did on this. Much better than a straight, setup photo of milk and cookies. It elevates it to the level of a cartoon, kind of bright and happy and childish.
This shows visible banding effects on my monitor -- not sure if it's intentional or not. If it is it has the effect of making it look partly "real" (esp. the cookies) and partly like an illustration. I'd have rotated it slightly to the right.
This has posibilitys, it looks like you used an effect, maybe solorize or somthing.Maybe its just the pixelization due to image compression. Im not sure that this effect works with this image. It is very interesting and i like it but it seems to be missing somthing.
Solarize! Got any DQ requests? This is totally legal, I recognize the effect. It does give this a surreal, impressionistic view of this very recognizable standard. I like it! The rims of the glass and plate tell me the focus is good, but this effect might fool some into thinking the focus isn't so good. 8 Swash
Posterize/equalize? Nice job and looks good. The perspective makes the glass look a little tilted to me. ? Good luck in the challenge. I like your idea.
Cool idea. I like this a lot. I'm one of those hardcore photo people though as far as challenge pics go. This is great digital art, but not a high quality photograph. It might be, but who can tell with all the overprocessing? - Inspzil
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
