This is a great closeup. looks near perfect.Focus is a little soft and you've got some pixelation on the milk bowl/dish? Probably unavoidable from having to reduce or compress this image for the guidlines. I still love it.
Cute... but it seems kind of low res and jaggy, with harsh lighting on the whiskers. But I really like the composition of this. It's a very appealing photo.
Good job, although I would rather the bowl wasn't there. I assume this wasn't a fun shot to take as the "model" probably didn't listen to directions well!
I'm a sucker for animal shots, plus this one is really nice. Like the lighting a lot, too bad you got some artifacts in the whiskers on the left. The drop on the chin is wonderful.
A really great idea that works as a parody of the "Got Milk?" campaign. Whille I recognize how difficult the shot probably was to get, I could wish for a slightly cleaner composition. I hesitate to point out the pixellated quality of the shot since I'm sure you know about it and Im doubly sure others will point it out. Cropped from a larger image? You might have tried presenting a slightly smaller image to minimize this problem.
This isn't the best picture of the challenge, but my personal favorite. Great idea, pretty well captured. The image does look like it has some clarity issues and maybe some resolution issues. I really like this pic though - Inspzil