Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Nice detail shot, but I would prefer the light reflecting off the pine cone to be more subdued (too bright). I might also prefer more crispness on the needles (but that might distract from the pine cone).
Post actions
Great photo, but I'm sorry, I can't score it as highly in a landscape challenge.
Post actions
I'm probably not alone in saying that I'm not sure this qualifies for a "landscape" picture. It's a very nice macro, and worth high marks, but I have to take one or so off for not meeting the challenge (I don't mark down hugely for that).
Post actions
this is a wonderful macro of a pinecone. I guess I just don't see how this is a landscape though.
Post actions
Post actions
Great Macro. I'll take away 2 because the title is a stretch. Jacko 8
Post actions
Great photo of a pine cone. Doesn't have too much to do with landscape though. Focus and lighting look great. 7 waltoml.
Post actions
Belongs in a macro challenge. Would be a 7 or 8.
Post actions
Hey, works for me! Great macro. and DOF
Post actions
great shot, but does not meet the challenge IMHO of course. :)
Post actions
I don't feel this portrays 'landscape'. My opinion...
Post actions
Nice colours, nice layout. Good job on the focusing too. A little more abstract to the concept of "landscape" for my taste, but a good photo. 7
Post actions
Nice photo, although I am not sure it fits into the landscape category.
Post actions
Post actions
Beautiful picture of pine cone...love the clarity of cone and needles...GREAT job
Post actions
You wont fool anybody into believing this is a landscape by the title.
Post actions
This is a beautiful photo. Nice and clear, great colors. But dosent meet the challenge of ;andscape for me. sorry4
Post actions
This is a nice shot of a pinecone. I think if the cone was at the left of the frame it would be better. A nice use of dof as well. Colours are sharp, and the cone is in focus. I scored you lower though, as IMO it does not meet the challenge. jgillard4
Post actions
Nice macro , bad landscape .
Post actions
I like the thought, but the focus is soft.
Post actions
Post actions
Looks a tad bit out of focus.
Post actions
It's a bit too macro for me. Maybe seeing the pinecone in the context of the tree(s) would have been better.
Post actions
Post actions
Nice capture, but seems to be a bit off-topic. Sorry.
Post actions
Good macro shot with great DOF.
Post actions
So many photos are of land, and most have so little clarity... nice to see your photo with such vibrant colors and focus. It just _looks_ cold too! (8)
Post actions
Beautiful macro, where's the land?? Cool idea.
Post actions
Excellent photo, but I'm not sure how well it's going to do in the landscape category. :)
Post actions
How could I comment on a photo like this one in a "landscape" contest?
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
