Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Your diagional composition works. The print is a bit muddy. The biggest problem is the presentation as your border is just plain bad.
Post actions
I like the photograph for the submission, however, I don't feel the border adds anything to the composition of the shot. If anything it is detracting.
Post actions
The border turns me off a bit. It's well balanced enough, like a good mat, but the photo edges are a bit cliched. Against the stark white, the body of the photo looks dim by comparison. The diagonal composition is the trickiest composition for me and I have a lot of trouble making it work. In this case, it doesn't help highlight the subject very well. Sorry to seem negative. I'm relatively new to this so these are just my opinions.
Post actions
Very interesting perspective. Not sure about the frame, though.
Post actions
I find the border overwhelming as the image is dark
Post actions
Ohhhh not another comment about the border :-)
Post actions
The framing seems unnecessarry here. It detracts from the neat (as in clean) repitition of the heater grate.
Post actions
I would never guess. It's not validated yet, but I trust it meets the challenge rules. 9.
Post actions
I dislike the border, it makes it hard to see the subject.
Post actions
I like the framing - makes a simple picture great.
Post actions
I don't think that kind of frames are allowed in this challenge
Post actions
i don't like the boarder otherwise good pic.
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.