You all hate this photo, I know, because you think it is a complete rip off...well it sort of is. this was a black piece of paper taped to my desk with my computer reflecting sonifos awesome pic on a cd that i waved under the reflection. yes you hate this, and I predict my score will be a 3.5
Statistics
Place: 213 out of 219 Avg (all users): 4.0045 Avg (commenters): 4.1333 Avg (participants): 4.0078 Avg (non-participants): 4.0000 Views since voting: 1156 Votes: 224 Comments: 18 Favorites: 0
I seen your post in the forums on how you did this. Very very creative work. And thanks for using my picture. I think this sort of thing is hard for people to except here. Can't wait to see what else you pull out of your hat!
CC is here!
Hello Achiral. I'm struck by your photographers comments, it's the first I've seen it. Sonifo should feel flattered.
Fits The Challenge-No, and it shows by the score you received. Wow they beat you up. I don't mind that it's a photo of a landscape and I can be picky. :) It's an attractive photo, with great colors.
Composition-Very nice. This could be a mock up for a professional CD label. It's different and _sometimes_ different at DPC won't fly.
Background-n/a
Digital Processing-Fair, nothing strikes me as too much or too little. Because it's a monitor it's not very sharp.
My Opinion-I like it for the colors and the creativity. It was a cool idea, just the wrong challenge. You know: Can't please all the peeps all the time. I think I know that lesson better then anyone here!!!
Thanks for letting me review your photo Achiral. Keep clicking your young and have wonderful new ideas and inventive creativity.
Every challenge there is a photo of a computer or monitor and i thought it couldn`t happen with a landscape challenge. How wrong i was.
I score you 4 for fitting the challenge without getting out of your chair.
The effect used is neat, but I do not think that this photo delivers what you would like to the viewer. What is the point of the cd? Is it to show off that you know how to reflect light? ;) Just the image that you have reflected would of resulted in my giving you a higher score. jgillard4
Hey Nice picture. Where did you take that shot.
Ok, it took me awhile to think about how I felt about this. I am not upset that you used my photo. I am a little flattered. Does it meet the challenge? yes. Do I like the technique? I would say ya to a point. I wish I knew more about how you did this. It almost looks like a t.v. screen. Is it really reflecting off of the disc? Very impressive if it is. Good luck in the challenge.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
