This shot turned out great - no cropping in photoshop, and the only real post prosessing was desaturating the yellow glove and enhancing the red food coloring.
I think this photo will shock many in a seamingly "open" challenge :)
Statistics
Place: 137 out of 188 Avg (all users): 4.8146 Avg (commenters): 5.4118 Avg (participants): 4.7807 Avg (non-participants): 4.8571 Views since voting: 1613 Votes: 205 Comments: 18 Favorites: 0
This photo definitely does have some shock value and it does seem to represent the song title. There are several things that I don't care for, however. The scene seems too bright to represent an act so dark. I think it would have worked much better with a dark background and only a single light source barely lighting the bloody gloves. The glove itself seems wrong for this. The white color is fine but the style and texture doesn't really go with murder. It looks more like a gardening glove or a kitchen glove. The knife is pretty cool even though it is quite short. I think I would have worked on the composition some more by having the glove at a more severe angle to the knife as if they were just dropped or tossed in that position. Technically it is very good, sharp and detailed. What is basically lacking for me is the mood of such a grissly act. I think you needed to go further than the blood and knife and really experiment with different lighting situations. 5 -Tim
A bit edgy for this crowd, don't you think? Very sharp, clear photo. The blood on the fingers seems more convincing than that on the blade (wonder why?) I don't know the song, but I will take your word for it, esp. since you bothered to include the band name (thanks, that helped!) 7 Swash
it seems to be out of focus, in the wrong places. Oh, uh, sorry, actually it is a perfect picture. Absolutely no flaws whatsoever-honest, I was just kidding about the focus. please...no..no...ahhhhhhhhhhh
just a little head's up, you might not wanna let your guidance counselor get ahold of this. and taking the knife to school will definately get you sent home early. stabbing somebody's kind of an extreme length to go to for a dpchallenge, but i gotta admire your determination.
Too gruesome for me. Even though it is only make believe. The knife is out of focus at the handle and the fingers of the glove are out of focus on the two sides. Just can't deal with it personally. 3 PTL