I have moved this one around several times. I think it is beautiful and definitely something one might see in a travel magazine, but a little boring. I am going to stop moving it and leave it with a 7. Good job.
Beautiful sunset. Exposed perfectly. Love the textures in the sky and in the water. The diagonal made by the pier is placed just perfect. Good luck on the challenge!
Despite the high contrast, I really like this shot. Love the wispy cirrus clouds and their reflection on the still water. I don't really care for the dark lower right corner but that's probably the shoreline/bank and cannot be helped nor cropped out. Looks like there is a slight amount of vignetting but it looks good with the intense contrast as it helps to frame the sky. 10
Great exposure. Dramatic sunset while maintaining the reflection of clouds in the water is something I don’t often capture. And the detail of the clouds is maintained! I’m jealous!