I gave you a five on this shot. To me there is nothing really standing out. I do however like how you filled the frame and maybe should have given you a 6.
Interesting, different, could have been in a bet better focus. A decent photo, but not the same quality as a lot of the more asthetically pleasing entries.
this really fits the challenge as it looks exactly like a postcard - one of the few occassions where a border really compliments and improves the purpose of a shot. aesthetically, it's not exactly a beautiful shot, and consequently in terms of competition might not do that well. but i think it's unfaultable, original, and so different from the usual icelandic church thing going on. 10.
While this picture may not be the most expected photo for a challenge, it is definitely one that I would see in a travel book. I do like the semi-repetitive pattern in it. Also filling the frame with the shirts works very well. It does seem like it could be just a little sharper.