I gave you 5 for this, but I think I hovered between 4 and 5 before clicking. I quite like the limited range of colour but the main aspect that failed to grab me was the composition. You could have had all that chocolate, but more compactly and artistically arranged. It is just too spread out and scattered. I agree with others that the vignette did not help.
Mostly, the tones and colors are quite monotonous, and the composition is too cluttered. Perhaps half as many objects, but more varied (dark/milk/white chocolate...?) and for sure a different surface/bg. The white vignette further dilutes the already flat tones. I think this could also have worked as a macro.
I saw your post in the threads on this image. While I like the concept of the shot, there are several things about the image that really go against a good score. First, the image does not have good control of focus. The front edge of the crunchy candy bar in the right center is not in focus and this gives the impression the entire image is out of focus. Second, the choice of white vingette does not work as it has hard edges and is actually drawing our eyes away from the subject. Third, the image is cluttered with too much stuff. I understand that you want to speak to how chocolate is your 'drug' but the cocoa powder just looks messy and the composition with so many objects looks messy. Fourth, the line in the top third of the image seems to cut the scene in two (angling the shot more to have only the table as the background may have helped you. But to be honest, the choice of wood grain as the background gives this even more of a feeling of 'snapshot'.
I didn't vote, but had I, I would likely have given it no more than 4 because of the topics above.
For these type shots - staged 'studio' work - the image has to be perfectly lit, perfectly composed, and perfectly processed just to get you to 6.
I did not vote in this one (during my break from the site). However, the white vignette does not work for me and draws me out of the photo. In addtion, there appears to be too much going on that does not add anything to the photo (here's some chocolate, oh look what's that, oh more choclate and over there is some more chocolate...). A close up of one piece of chocolate dropping into melted chocolate (ala a commercial) might have had more impact.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
