The critique is great, and you really took the effort to read other people's comments and then base it a bit on that.
Good separation of topics and excellent the personalized treatment.
Did you send a PM so that the user knows you did a comment?
Thank you, I try to Critique like I would want one given and it helps me to really look at the photo. I based the seperation from some of the critiques I have received.
oops, I didn't PM them, I will go do that now. Thanks again.