Ok so I get a comment saying "who wants to go see a movie about ****" What?!?!? Just judge the freaking photo. I could care less if you don't want to see the movie, which is a good thing since there's no movie to see. This person also says my title is impossible. "How can a **** be ****?" Huh? It's a fictional movie NOT non-fiction. There are many genres in fiction one of them being science fiction. Why on earth are you focusing on the believabilty of the title when THAT'S NOT A REQUIREMENT OF THE CHALLENGE. Heck, if that was a requirement for real movie titles Hollywood wouldn't exist. I should have just done what others did and added a description to my title explaining the movie/genre. Unbelievable. I think the worse thing is this person thought it was a poster-like image. Heck, vote me done if you think my photo is junk but please quit with the DNMC crap. That does nothing but make me want to never enter another challenge again. My interest is to improve my photography not get you to like my stupid fictional movie.
Ok, rant over. :)
Edited to add: Those **** are just to avoid disclosing my entry.
I have voted on every entry, but haven't commmented yet. My requirements were that the title be a title as opposed to a description, and that the 3 words go together in some meaningful, "title-ish" way. I also looked at whether the photo went along in some way with the title.
The goals of the viewer is to give an acurate critique of the image using the knowledge they have within photography.
If a viewer has remarks that are out of line, than that viewer needs to understand the art, the rules, and the goals of each challenge before they commit to a comment.
