You notice that the photo you are critiquing has violated the challenge rules. What do you do?
For the record, I gave the critique as though the image were legal, but did notice that in the editing steps listed, the photographer had listed steps that violated the rules. There are a few reasons for this, but I feel bad about it, I recommended a DQ after writing the critique.
Questions:
Would you have given the critique or just gone for the DQ request?
Would it have affected your critique?
Would you ignore it since the challenge is over?
I really am interested to hear some honest responses to the questions.
Message edited by author 2005-11-07 12:52:11. |
