after i finish the challenge i went back to my orginal foto and made this to the foto! after the comments i got i tried to make it better! comments please especial to the people who said that brighter and with less noise would be nicer! i like the emproved foto! what do you think?
after the challenge original
I liked the original, and I gave it a 6. IMO, the original is MUCH better than the edited one. I think many people on here don't have their monitors calibrated correctly and see things much too dark.
I think the new one is a little too bright now, as the others have said.. I'd like to see a happy medium.
As for having monitors calibrated.. If mine was any brighter, I wouldn't be able to *see* the color black (it'd be a dark grey).. and the first photo is still a little too dark for my tastes.
yup i changed it but just a little! but thanks anyway for the opinion! sorry to be keep on going with the thread but i liked the photo and i know i didn't not express myself that much to get the thing i wanted! still have to work on it! thats why my questioning of it look better! but seems i'll have to take it outside again and start a new shoot! thanks anyway! :) and keep klicking!
I like the third one best. The second one was indeed too bright.
I got an impression you used neatimage or some other noise-removing tool. I would recomend using it on the sky but not the telescop as it looks plastic. I would say telescope from original and sky from the last one would make a perfect match.
Am I wrong about the anti-noising?
btw. I gave it a 6 (6+ actually, meaning 6 with tendency to up)
keep smiling
Wu
I was one of those that commented on your photo during the challenge. I rated the original a 5 and would have rated either one of the others probably a 7. Maybe if there had been a bit more of an even light on the telescope, that would have helped. I like the originality of this idea.
