You have rated 66 of 66 images (100%) in this challenge.
You have commented on 1 images (2%) in this challenge.
You have given an average score of 6.2727.
This one was very hard to score. Not sure whether to vote on artistic value on the pumpkin or on the overall quality of the image..
Not sure whether to vote on artistic value on the pumpkin or on the overall quality of the image..
Sayeth the Langdon " This challenge is as much about the pumpkin as it is about the photography" so neither one way nor the other, just hit it up the middle.
Not sure whether to vote on artistic value on the pumpkin or on the overall quality of the image..
I'd say it is a photography site not a pumpkin carving site. I saw some great photos with so-so pumpkins and some lousy photos of great pumpkins, and some great photos of great pumpkins. I'm looking for great photos.
I'd say the top photos should be a combination of both a great photo and great carving. but I won't vote a photo down if it is a really fun idea that is photographed well with a simple carving. The carving doesn't have to be really technical to be good. You can carve a simple pumpkin with triangle eyes and a crescent mouth well or some people can even mess that up.
You have rated 65 of 65 images (100%) in this challenge.
You have commented on 3 images (5%) in this challenge.
You have given an average score of 5.8462.
add some more comments when ive got more time, work time now some cracking ones shame mine didnt come off as planned, next year the dremmels coming out hehe
Not sure whether to vote on artistic value on the pumpkin or on the overall quality of the image..
I'd say it is a photography site not a pumpkin carving site. I saw some great photos with so-so pumpkins and some lousy photos of great pumpkins, and some great photos of great pumpkins. I'm looking for great photos.
I'm giving anyone who carved a pumpkin an extra point for being a good sport and entering at all.
I carved. I entered. I failed. On to the next photography challenge please.
You have rated 66 of 66 images (100%) in this challenge.
You have commented on 27 images (41%) in this challenge.
You have given an average score of 6.7424.
I think there are some fantastic images in this challenge. So much fun!! I took a point off if the pumpkin wasn't carved as it is a "pumpkin carving challenge" but overall fantastic work by everyone who entered.
