There is another thread Commenting Setup running that talks about ranking comments, and it contains some good dialog. But, I thought we should have a thread where we could post comments that are examples of being very helpful. I chose a few from last week's challenges entries as examples, and invite others to do the same.
Originally posted by kevrobertson:
Nice puddy cat
the grass across his face is a little distracting
but i'm not going to move it
well done
good luck with the challange |
I thought: "LMAO. How did he read my photographers notes? But he is right, taking that picture was an amazing experience, but as a challenge entry, it has flaws."
Originally posted by melismatica:
Very nice travel photo. I don't see anything out of the ordinary, though. |
I thought: "Rhode Island has no large cities. Might be a lot of people that feel that way. Wish I had thought of that earlier"
Originally posted by photom:
Gorgeous scene, nice colors and lighting. Seems a bit over saturated. |
I thought: "Note to self: you get the oversaturated comment frequently. Go figure out what that means."
Note: thanks to all other commenters on my photos. I just ran out of space in this thread.
|
