where do you get the 'reason' for reject ? I don't seem to see any on my rejected images.
If there is no reason/comments listed under the image, then it did not make it to member screening. I find that frustrating, but I understand they screen a lot of images. Too bad the original screener can't use the drop down menus that we see in member screening.
"Comments from members:
absolutely yes!!
Nice one!
Great capture ...very joyful!
I think I would have likesd a person more or less in focus, but this shouts "missing..." and that pleases me also.
Additional feedback: Of those who voted against your image, five indicated that there is a problem with sharpness, one noted disturbing objects as a weakness and one selected composition as a reason for not publishing the image."
Seeing as how there is no way I can "correct" the "problem with sharpness", I don't see any reason to submit for critique or potentially try it again. Best shot I've had in awhile, though.
"Comments from members:
absolutely yes!!
Nice one!
Great capture ...very joyful!
I think I would have likesd a person more or less in focus, but this shouts "missing..." and that pleases me also.
Additional feedback: Of those who voted against your image, five indicated that there is a problem with sharpness, one noted disturbing objects as a weakness and one selected composition as a reason for not publishing the image."
Seeing as how there is no way I can "correct" the "problem with sharpness", I don't see any reason to submit for critique or potentially try it again. Best shot I've had in awhile, though.
I think Hajeka has a good suggestion. Although I like it as is, maybe blur the partially in focus rider.
I've never intentionally blurred anything in post processing - I think mostly because when I try to do it, it always looks fake. I'll go take a look at your critique request.
well I thought this might get in as a 1x style photo but NO. haha great.
Comment from screener: Your picture has been evaluated both by the site crew and the members. The common decision was to not publish.
Comments from members:
* A great one, with a wonderful light !
Additional feedback: Of those who voted against your image, one indicated that there is a problem with editing, one noted technical quality as a weakness and one selected composition as a reason for not publishing the image.
I hadn't submitted anything in a while so last week I submitted one from my NYC vacation. I was fully expecting to show it here in this thread, surprisingly it was accepted!
well I thought this might get in as a 1x style photo but NO. haha great.
Comment from screener: Your picture has been evaluated both by the site crew and the members. The common decision was to not publish.
Comments from members:
* A great one, with a wonderful light !
Additional feedback: Of those who voted against your image, one indicated that there is a problem with editing, one noted technical quality as a weakness and one selected composition as a reason for not publishing the image.
it seems perfect for 1x. Dark, mysterious, man with disability, etc.
got some good feedback from the critique forum and an edited version got published
They're actually pretty cool about helping out. I resubmitted this after reading the critiques when it was originally rejected. Same setup, different shot, but I was allowed to reupload the new frame and it got accepted.
got some good feedback from the critique forum and an edited version got published
They're actually pretty cool about helping out. I resubmitted this after reading the critiques when it was originally rejected. Same setup, different shot, but I was allowed to reupload the new frame and it got accepted.
louis, that's a wonderful shot! already added to my 1x.com favorites :)
