Guitar Sounds
by Lydia

Comment:
I love the composition here with the framing of the guitar. Vignette is a bit strong. I'd be curious to see a version with fewer or perhaps no notes to see what I would prefer.

(You Don't Believe We're On) The Eve Of Destruction
by GeneralE

Comment:
No comments always sucks.

I liked this one and was your 7. The colors and the textures are very interesting and the shapes are well composed in the frame. I am guessing the 2's and 3's were looking for a more identifiable subject.

Pinwheel
by MaryO

Comment:
I really liked this one and had it ranked pretty high. The colors are great and the fact that only the flower has a twirl and the background does not really makes it pop. The two 3's are certainly outliers here.

Escalator
by DistantColours

Comment:
No comments always sucks.

This was my top pick in the challenge. The colored lighting and the stairs leading to a vanishing point are really strong. Perhaps take the image a tiny bit earlier and get the man full silhouetted against the yellow. You could also clone out the distractions over his right and left shoulder to really isolate the figure.

Harry Potter's work bench
by blindjustice

Comment:
I like the composition with all the shapes and colors. I think it mostly meets the challenge given how broad the challenge is. Perhaps a another title like "Now where did I put that..." or similar would work better as the Harry Potter connection eludes me.

The Stories Between Us
by markwiley

Comment:
Nicely caught moment. So many candids are of random moments, but the expressions of their faces is a moment of great interest.

when your hair stands on end ... you'll know
by glad2badad

Comment:
Great sky and I love the contrast. Perhaps either crop to remove the town/farms or go wider and include more of it.

triple sets of fire escape stairs and, incidentally, 21 window air conditioner units.
by PennyStreet

Comment:
Great bit of seeing. I like the repetition both on the horizon and vertical. Perhaps shoot wider and then try some perspective correction. Title is a bit much.

Glass Bottle Abstract
by Wildpurple

Comment:
This one spoke to me. The muted tones and the abstract yet familiar texture. I gave it a 7 and thought it would do much better than this.

Peaceful Sounds
by MReeve1874

Comment:
Love the composition with the texture and the various lines. Took my a bit to recognize it at first it out as it is so graphic in nature. Perhaps having one of string vibrating would be something to try. Also perhaps more a "sound" image than a "noise" image.