Comment: Great idea for this difficult assignment, I like your composition, and the colors, I think if you had positioned the duck to see a complete reflection you would have a wow shot and get the duck completely in focus. Don't give up on this one, I would love to see your photo if you re-shoot it.
Comment: Nice composition, you are going to get a lot of negative comments for not having more blue in the background showing, but I like the overall effect of this photo, good work.
Comment: Cute title, I think you did a hell-a of a good job with what sounds to me to be a difficult challenge: your composition is excellent, love the colors.