| Challenge Results for Plastiface |
 |
Monica
by markwiley
21st place with an
average vote of 4.8448
Views: 514 (141 during voting)
Votes: 58
|
Your Vote: N/A
Your Comment: N/A
Average Vote (Participants): 4.824
Average Vote (Non-Participants): 4.854
|
|
 |
in the know
by jmritz
22nd place with an
average vote of 4.7627
Views: 340 (119 during voting)
Votes: 59
|
Your Vote: N/A
Your Comment: N/A
Average Vote (Participants): 4.778
Average Vote (Non-Participants): 4.756
|
|
 |
plastidude
by HUETH
23rd place with an
average vote of 4.6441
Views: 455 (110 during voting)
Votes: 59
|
Your Vote: N/A
Your Comment: N/A
Average Vote (Participants): 4.706
Average Vote (Non-Participants): 4.619
|
|
 |
open wide
by tvsometime
24th place with an
average vote of 4.5862
Views: 457 (122 during voting)
Votes: 58
|
Your Vote: N/A
Your Comment: N/A
Average Vote (Participants): 4.529
Average Vote (Non-Participants): 4.610
|
|
 |
Petrochemical Mummy
by GeneralE
25th place with an
average vote of 4.1017
Views: 465 (116 during voting)
Votes: 59
|
Your Vote: N/A
Your Comment: N/A
Average Vote (Participants): 4.056
Average Vote (Non-Participants): 4.122
|
|
| Disqualified Images |
 |
you Must Be Kidding Me!
by Refocused
Originally 7th place with an
average vote of 5.7931
Views: 673 (132 during voting)
Votes: 58
|
Your Vote: N/A
Your Comment: N/A
Disqualification Message:
This has been the subject of a lot of SC discussion and has led to a 7:1 vote for a DQ.
Even with the most liberal interpretation of removing distracting elements, this photo breaks a rule as it is written. The rules indicate that where distracting elements are removed, they must be replaced by what would have been there (I.e. behind the removed element).
The creation of the shadow, within the cloned in/out area breaks this rule.
That’s not to say that all SC agreed that what was removed was a ‘distracting element’ but it became a moot debate because of the shadow being added where there wouldn’t have been one. |
|
